Friday, April 17, 2015

Confusion with chapters 20-24



Chapters twenty to twenty four are very complex chapters that I did not understand. These four chapters are interior monologues by Beloved, Denver, and Sethe. The style of these chapter are very confusing and is very similar to poetry. I spoke with someone and tried to figure out where exactly the three women where. Ms. Lord explained to me that some people believe that they were on a slave ship. They kept talking about how the "men without skin" were throwing off dead African Americans into the sea. I reread these chapters, and a few things made more sense in the aspect of them being on a slave ship. This made me wonder, why were they on a slave ship? Beloved has most likely never been on a slave ship and if she has she would not have remembered it. So it is most likely that they are not literally on a slave ship. So then what does the slave ship symbolize? We knew Beloved was dead, so we questioned if there was a connection about where they were and Beloved being dead. Then it came to me, There is a famous saying in funerals that they person may be dead but they are not gone, they are in everyone hearts because that person will be remembered. Is this why Beloved is haunting Sethe so strongly. Everyone thought about Beloved all of the time before Paul D came into the picture. Is Beloved in between life and death? She is physically dead but her spirit is strong and alive. While Sethe on the other hand was the opposite. She may have been physically alive but she was mentally gone. She is stuck in the past and all she thinks about is Beloved. Nobody really did care about her or spoke with her except Denver. This explains why they are both on the slave ship. The Slave ship represents the in between of life and death, which helps me comprehend these four chapters a bit more.

6 comments:

  1. WOW! Your ideas about the slave ship being a symbol is something that I never thought of, but now that you bring it up, it makes a lot more sense. I took am extremely confused about these chapters no matter how many times I reread them. One thing related to this to maybe think about is the idea about why Morrison chose to write these last chapters as "monologues" and from the perspective of just one character.

    ReplyDelete
  2. This analyzation of the slave ship is very impressive. It really helps me comprehend these chapters way better. I really like how you explained that physically Beloved is dead but remembered by heart. For Sethe its the opposite physically she's alive but emotionally she is dead. They are both in the in-between of life and death. Keep up the good work Sirena!

    ReplyDelete
  3. This is such great analysis and comparison of the physical and mental states of Beloved and Sethe. It makes me think about how Sethe wanted to save Beloved by killing her, which everyone thought was crazy. After reading your blog, I realize that Sethe did save Beloved, she just saved her spiritual form. Good job!

    ReplyDelete
  4. This is such great analysis and comparison of the physical and mental states of Beloved and Sethe. It makes me think about how Sethe wanted to save Beloved by killing her, which everyone thought was crazy. After reading your blog, I realize that Sethe did save Beloved, she just saved her spiritual form. Good job!

    ReplyDelete
  5. This blog is just really good at analyzing Beloved and Sethe. I get why Sethe killed Beloved because in her mind she thought that by killing her she is protecting her from white people getting her "dirty". Awesome Job Sirena!!!

    ReplyDelete
  6. I had trouble with this too, but after reading blogs with the perspectives of different people I found it much clearer by seeing Beloved as a succubus which is a creature that haunts male people while they are asleep and steals their semen. WHile Sethe is a woman it still seems pretty close as Beloved seemed to drain Sethe of her energy, and if you read ahead to when Paul D could not sleep in the same room each time you could imagine the reason as Beloved haunting him in his sleep and sexually assaulting him. One specific event of this was when Paul D ws in the Shed trying to sleep and Beloved came to him at night and tried seducing him. Great work on analyzing the ship and its meaning!

    ReplyDelete